(no subject)
Jun. 3rd, 2023 12:42 pmShould I put that the fairly significant age difference between Jared Harris and Paul Anderson on top of Moriarty being quite upper class while Moran appears to be working class in AGoS may have been deliberately trying to suggest that the more privileged Moriarty was 'exploiting' Moran in more ways than one? (I mean... this was an era of shit like the 'Cleveland Street scandal' and all the stuff about 'telegraph boys being exploited by older usually aristocratic men'). I am tempted to put that.
I'm not saying any 'intimate' relationship between them is actually dubious - Moran is clearly way over the age of consent and even if he's unable to actually leave Moriarty's employment he seems perfectly capable of standing up to Moriarty in that regard and I think the elements which appear to deliberately parallel the Holmes and Watson relationship do emphasise that the relationship between Moriarty and Moran is a very genuine one - but it does really feel like the decision to make Moriarty more 'aristocratic' than he is canonically while making Moran far more working class when canonically he probably comes from a background of way more privilege than Moriarty, while also making Moran noticeably younger than Moriarty... put that on top of Moriarty never being shown to have a wife or any kind of female 'love interest' and this being set within only 2 years of the Cleveland Street scandal (I never actually realised til now that was SO close to that, which is very interesting for this film and for the canon too)... I think they were deliberately insinuating something there.
I'm not saying any 'intimate' relationship between them is actually dubious - Moran is clearly way over the age of consent and even if he's unable to actually leave Moriarty's employment he seems perfectly capable of standing up to Moriarty in that regard and I think the elements which appear to deliberately parallel the Holmes and Watson relationship do emphasise that the relationship between Moriarty and Moran is a very genuine one - but it does really feel like the decision to make Moriarty more 'aristocratic' than he is canonically while making Moran far more working class when canonically he probably comes from a background of way more privilege than Moriarty, while also making Moran noticeably younger than Moriarty... put that on top of Moriarty never being shown to have a wife or any kind of female 'love interest' and this being set within only 2 years of the Cleveland Street scandal (I never actually realised til now that was SO close to that, which is very interesting for this film and for the canon too)... I think they were deliberately insinuating something there.